15 Comments
User's avatar
Clive Agran's avatar

A very moving piece.

Expand full comment
Alex Stein's avatar

Thanks Clive

Expand full comment
Robert F. Graboyes's avatar

Incredibly poignant piece.

Expand full comment
Alex Stein's avatar

Many thanks Robert!

Expand full comment
Éamann Mac Donnchada's avatar

Agree with the above comments. Seems incredible in retrospect that these communities had only a handful of people with firearms

Expand full comment
Éamann Mac Donnchada's avatar

Most of my friends on the left regard the fate of the victims as terrible but somehow in some way deserved or at least inevitable, somewhat akin to that of German civilians raped and slaughtered by the advancing Red Army. Zionism is now seen as the supreme global evil and Israeli Jews as its essential practitioners. All means must be deployed to defeat it, and them, no matter how terrible

Expand full comment
David Lehmann's avatar

You still call them friends?

Expand full comment
David Lehmann's avatar

Excellent reportage. Lets the bare facts speak so emotional embellishment is superfluous, and would even diminish the effect.

Expand full comment
Alex Stein's avatar

Thanks David!

Expand full comment
Joan Randall's avatar

My heart is broken for these beautiful lives destroyed.

Expand full comment
Tony Coren's avatar

Moving insightful piece. I had no.isea Moshe Dayan was such an eloquent poet (see link at the end to "The Gates of Gaza)

Expand full comment
Alex Stein's avatar

Thanks Tony!

Expand full comment
Tony Coren's avatar

Suggested translatn:

"To my lover Eitan

You died a hero

Saving those near & dear to you

I will never forget you

I love you so much

Your darling Francaise

Expand full comment
Jill's avatar

How can one arrange a visit to Be'eri or any other kibbutz attacked on October 7th?

Expand full comment
Alex Stein's avatar

I was invited on a visit as I had helped translate the bios of people murdered on October 7.

Expand full comment